In Kim Stanley Robinson’s book, New York 2140, the city is flooded from seawater rise, the poor are huddled in the intertidal zone, and the rich live in superscrapers uptown, their giant lofts and condos towering above the destruction. After a particularly juiced-up hurricane, the city’s poor are left homeless, living in Central Park. That is, they live there until they realize: most of the apartments uptown are sitting empty, their foreign owners using them as investment piggy banks. So they form a Householder’s Union and revolt.
Take out the flooding and the uprising and Robinson’s book could just as easily be titled New York 2018. All along the Central Park corridor and the Financial District, high-rise luxury condos are stabbing at the sky. The lean 432 Park Avenue tops out at 1,396 feet, making it the tallest residential building in the country, while the One57 building stands at 1005 feet. In the next few years, many more luxury skyscrapers will join them. Speculation on these condos has driving up housing prices by 30 percent in one year.
And in a city where rents are increasing at double the rates of income and homelessness is at its highest level since the Great Depression, one condo recently sold for a record-breaking $88 million.
But a recent Census Bureau inquiry found something even more sobering: 30 percent of all apartments in the area between 49th to 70th Streets from Fifth to Park are vacant at least ten months a year, and 30 percent of owners are foreigners. That means that the mind-numbingly expensive apartments aren’t even being used for living. They’re used, instead, as an investment, a secure place for the global mega-rich to deposit their money as their favorite old haunts—Switzerland and the Cayman Islands—have succumbed to at least some requirements for transparency. And thanks to a loophole in the Patriot Act, which monitors all formal financial institutions, real estate transactions are exempt from oversight. That has allowed a shadow-world of lawyers, brokers and financial advisors who cater to the planet’s 1 percent, forming LLCS and shell companies that give buyers total anonymity.
That means a Manhattan pied-a-terre is the perfect place for oligarchs to funnel their ill-got millions, avoid taxation or cover up scandal, or launder money. But on a more practical level, it means that Manhattan’s economy—and its housing—is both catered to and run by plutocrats who can’t be discovered, taxed, or held accountable. In the process, everyday New Yorkers suffer the consequences, seeing the constriction in housing supply lead to a glut of housing demand, allowing both realtors and landlords to charge obscene housing prices.
Of course, there are things that could be done to keep Manhattan from become one giant land bank. The advocacy group, Generation Rent, has proposed an idea keeps hypercapitalism intact but provides a second-tier welfare state for the rest of us. They propose creating a secondary housing market, where the government would invests billions in real estate and then sells the houses to residents at cost, then regulate the appreciation at a rate similar to a savings account. Critics argue that this does nothing to stop the proliferation of luxury apartments or foreign investment, and argue for a massive increase in affordable housing, taxes and penalties for foreign investors, and more transparency and oversight in the buying process. Of course, Robinson himself has sketched out another, if fictionalized, approach: a Householder’s Union that threatens a debtor’s strike unless the government turns over empty luxury apartments to the people. No matter what, though, New York’s affordable housing future depends on including the reality of luxury vacancies in its calculation of housing supply and demand.
8/24/2021 12:01:38 am
Excellent article! Your post is essential today. Thanks for sharing, by the way.
9/18/2022 12:16:01 am
Great article! Thank you for sharing this informative post, and looking forward to the latest one.
12/9/2022 03:22:22 pm
We improve our clients’ lives by enhancing their houses, giving them a place to relax, reconnect, and revitalize while feeling proud of their achievements and home. Stones and Cabinets City delights our customers and makes them proud of their houses by making the complex simple.
12/9/2022 03:28:15 pm
We are keen on improving the quality of life for our drivers and their families by providing the best technology, higher pay, premium benefits, and ensuring efficient operations and load planning that lets them maximize their home life without sacrificing safety or income.
12/9/2022 03:29:37 pm
Knowledgeable and expert technicians at I-Cell Station identify your cell phone issues for free so that we can offer you the best possible solutions. We have expert-level solutions for all damaged cell phone devices, from screen replacements to charging ports and batteries, cameras speakers, back glass to motherboard level repairs.
12/9/2022 03:31:00 pm
Blogging refers to writing, photography, and other media that's self-published online. Blogging started as an opportunity for individuals to write diary-style entries, but it has since been incorporated into websites for many businesses.
12/9/2022 03:32:09 pm
At HFC Pizza & Subs we serve Pizza & Italian cuisine using only the freshest ingredients. You can also choose from our selection appetizers, salads, cheesesteaks, heros and much much more!!!!!
1/3/2023 07:47:00 pm
Digital Marketing Houston: Informatics Commerce is a leading digital marketing houston agency provides complete digital marketing services to various businesses around the globe.
2/7/2023 02:35:17 pm
Magento Development Chicago: Informatics IMS is a leading magento development chicago company in USA providing magento development services to top giant ecommerce stores.
Leave a Reply.